What Is Performance Privilege? Why Managers Say They’d Grant Top Performers More Exceptions
Fundamentals

What Is Performance Privilege? Why Managers Say They’d Grant Top Performers More Exceptions

Uncover the patterns of performance privilege in the workplace and its implications for rule enforcement among employees.

Created by

Pat Hartonian
Pat Hartonian Chief Compliance Officer

In GCheck’s The Performance Privilege Report, 49% of managers in the quality-checked sample backed a policy exception for a top performer who knowingly submitted a duplicate expense, against 27% for a typical performer. The report calls that pattern Performance Privilege: the same rule, read differently depending on who broke it.

Key Takeaways

  • Rule-breaking is ordinary: 81% of 2,000 US workers have personally seen at least one of six kinds of violation, so how it gets handled matters more than whether it happens.
  • Performance Privilege is the tendency for an employee’s performance level to change how a manager reads and responds to the same conduct. It describes a pattern across managers, never an individual.
  • Before the facts were settled, managers were more certain a top performer’s duplicate expense was an honest mistake (37% “very likely” vs. 24% for a typical performer).
  • After a confirmed violation, investigation and formal action held steady. The exception moved: 49% vs. 27% in the quality-checked sample, and 44% vs. 33% on all responses.
  • Trust follows performance more than oversight does: 83% of managers trust their highest performer’s judgment, against 61% for a typical performer.
  • Managers’ stated reasons lean toward trust more than retention: trust-based reasons outnumbered retention-based ones, 30% to 21%.
  • Managers know the standard: 81% say policy should apply equally, 59% say high performers get more leniency where they work, and half agree with both.
  • After a confirmed violation, 62% of coworkers expected management to handle a top performer’s case the same way it would for anyone, against 72% for a typical performer.
  • The report points to the exception itself as the most direct lever: a written reason, reviewed outside the reporting line, applied in both directions.

When Rule-Breaking Is Ordinary, Handling Becomes the Question

Rule-breaking at work is common. In the report’s survey of 2,000 employed US adults, 81% had personally seen at least one of six kinds of violation in a current or past workplace. Missed deadlines or failures to deliver agreed work led the list at 61%, followed by disrespecting or mistreating coworkers at 43% and attendance or punctuality violations at 37%. Only 19% had seen none of them.

When nearly everyone has seen it, the more useful question is how it gets handled, and whether the handling depends on who did it. The usual position is that a rule is a rule. The report tests the part of that statement that rarely gets audited: whether the same rule reads the same way when the person who broke it is the team’s best performer.

What Is Performance Privilege?

Performance Privilege is the tendency for an employee’s performance level to change how a manager reads and responds to the same conduct. The term describes a pattern across managers in the data. It is never a label for any individual manager or employee, and the shift could have run in either direction.

The report measures it in four places: in the benefit of the doubt a manager extends before the facts are settled, in the exception a manager grants after they are, in what managers say drove their decisions, and in what coworkers expect once someone reports the behavior. This article follows those four measures on the top-performer side of the comparison. The report also tested a low performer, and that comparison deserves its own article.

A name helps because each exception can be explained on its own terms, and any single explanation can be true. A name gives an organization a way to ask whether the explanations add up.

How the Study Was Run

The study surveyed 2,000 employed US adults on November 5, 2026, weighted by age, gender and region. Of those, 893 supervise at least one direct report. Each manager decided one case: an employee submits the same expense claim twice. Managers saw one of five versions, and the versions differed only in how much was known and how the employee performed.

No manager judged more than one employee, so any gap between versions comes from the description of the employee, not from the manager. The other 1,107 respondents answered as coworkers who noticed the duplicate. Every result was computed two ways: on all responses, and on a quality-checked sample that sets aside responses flagged for speeding, straight-lining or a failed comprehension check. Where the two differ materially, both appear here.

Managers were asked what they would do, so the results are stated intentions in a hypothetical case. People tend to understate behavior that reflects unevenly on their own fairness, which is why the gaps are best read as a floor.

Where Performance Privilege Shows Up

Before the facts are settled: the benefit of the doubt

In the ambiguous versions, it was not yet clear whether the duplicate was a mistake. Managers leaned toward an honest mistake for every employee: 77% for a top performer and 74% for a typical performer, a difference too small to read as real. Good faith was extended broadly.

The difference was in certainty. On identical facts, 37% of managers given a top performer said an honest mistake was “very likely,” against 24% given a typical performer. In the quality-checked sample the gap widens to 48% against 23%, though the typical-performer base there is under 100 and should be read as directional.

After the violation is confirmed: the exception

Once a review confirmed the duplicate as knowingly submitted, managers still investigated. 96% were very or somewhat likely to investigate further for both the typical and the top performer. Formal warning, discipline or escalation was recommended at similar rates, 68% for the typical performer and 64% for the top performer. The rule held.

The difference came in one decision, whether to set the policy aside. In the quality-checked sample, 49% of managers backed an exception for a top performer, against 27% for a typical performer, which makes managers 1.8 times as likely to back an exception for a top performer. On all responses the figures are 44% and 33%. In the report’s experience cut, the exception gap grows with managerial experience (3, 14 and 21 points across the three tenure groups), though tenure tracks age closely in this sample, so that pattern is directional. The formal consequence held steady. The exception is where performance moved the outcome.

Before any violation: trust and latitude

The pattern starts earlier than the violation. Among managers, 83% trust their highest performer’s judgment a great deal or quite a bit, against 61% for a typical performer. Discretion over how work is done runs in the same direction at a smaller scale, 62% against 50%. That trust gap is the one a manager carries into an ambiguous case, and it matches where the experiment found its effect: more certainty that a top performer meant no harm.

Oversight mostly does not fall as trust rises. More managers say they review their top performer’s work more closely than their peers’ (36%) than less closely (22%). Some of the trust is reasonable, and most teams run better when strong people are trusted. Where it stops is the open question: the work, or the rulebook.

Why Managers Say They Grant the Exception

Managers who decided the confirmed top-performer case were asked for the main factor behind their decision, and no single reason reached a majority. Grouped by type, trust-based reasons outnumbered retention-based ones, 30% to 21%, though one in five managers named retention directly.

Those stated reasons lean toward trust more than retention, and that shapes how an organization should respond. A manager extending trust to a reliable person is making an ordinary human judgment. The process still needs a way to record why.

Repeat behavior points the same way. 67% of managers would respond more harshly if the conduct had happened before, at similar rates for every performer. That points to the first incident as the place where judgment has the most room, and where a written reason does the most work.

Managers Know the Standard: Two Rulebooks

Ask managers what fair enforcement looks like and they agree almost unanimously: 81% say company policy should be enforced the same way regardless of performance. Yet 59% say that at their own organization, high performers receive more leniency when they break a rule, and 21% disagree. Half of all managers (50%) agree with both statements.

The report calls this Two Rulebooks: managers endorse one and describe a second. The rule is understood. The question is how it gets applied once a person is attached to it. Agreement that leniency exists was most common at organizations with 50 to 249 employees (66%) and least common under 50 employees (49%).

Consistency in discipline is a recurring recommendation outside this study as well. In the context of harassment, the co-chairs of the EEOC’s Select Task Force recommended in 2016 that discipline be consistent and not give, or create the appearance of, undue favor to any particular employee (U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission [EEOC], 2016). That recommendation concerns harassment discipline specifically.

What Coworkers Expect After Someone Speaks Up

The 1,107 non-managers read the same five versions as a coworker who noticed the duplicate. After a confirmed violation, 72% expected management to handle a typical performer’s case the same way it would for anyone. For a top performer, 62%. That leaves 38% of coworkers who read the confirmed top-performer version without expecting equal handling.

A 10-point gap in confidence matters because unreported problems are already common. The EEOC’s task force found that roughly three in four people who experienced harassment never talked to a supervisor, manager or union representative about it, most often out of fear of disbelief, inaction, blame or retaliation (EEOC, 2016). A coworker who doubts the outcome may have one more reason to stay quiet.

Four Practices That Put a Record Behind the Exception

What respondents asked for

Asked what would most help ensure consistent treatment regardless of performance, respondents ranked clear written criteria applied the same way to everyone first (57%) and a safe way to raise concerns about inconsistent treatment second (52%). Documentation required for any exception, lenient or harsh, drew 44%, with managers (47%) more likely than non-managers (41%) to ask for it. Nothing on the list asks for gentler standards or for closer scrutiny of employees.

The Society for Human Resource Management found that 76% of Americans say their manager sets the culture of their workplace (SHRM, 2019). The exception is the decision where a manager’s judgment shows most visibly, and the report’s four practices all work on it.

The four practices

Each practice puts a record behind the exception, and each has a finding behind it. It’s about being able to show why the rule bent.

PracticeWhat it puts on recordFinding behind it
Require a written rationale, reviewed outside the reporting line, for any exception to a conduct or expense policyWhy the policy was set aside, in either directionException gap of 49% vs. 27%; 44% of respondents asked for required documentation
Record the same incident details for every employee, whatever their ratingComparable facts, so comparisons rest on what happened81% of managers say policy should apply equally; 59% say high performers get more leniency
Give coworkers a channel to raise inconsistent treatment, and close the loop with themThat the concern was heard62% (top performer) vs. 72% (typical) expected equal handling; 52% asked for a safe channel
Train managers to name what is driving a decisionWhich factor drove the decisionTrust-based reasons 30% vs. retention-based 21%; 45% asked for manager training on separating trust from accountability

What a written reason can cover

A reasonable balance is a short written reason for each exception, not a long form for every judgment call. Four items are enough:

A human still makes each exception call, and the written reason is what keeps it consistent. Keep these records to the facts needed, limit who can see them, and follow the organization’s retention and privacy policies. Closing the loop with a coworker can mean confirming that a review took place without sharing confidential details about the outcome.

On the hiring side, GCheck’s Compliance Automation services, including Adverse Action Administration, address decisions that rely on a background check. Those decisions carry their own procedural requirements under the Fair Credit Reporting Act and, in many places, state and local fair-chance rules, and each applicant’s circumstances still call for individual review. The practices above address conduct decisions inside the workplace, which those services do not cover.

How these practices fit a given workforce depends on its policies and jurisdiction. State and local rules on workplace investigations, personnel records and protections for employees who raise concerns vary by location, and if an outside vendor supplies information for a review, federal and state consumer-reporting rules may apply. Qualified legal counsel should review these practices before adoption.

Conclusion

The rule held in the experiment. Investigation and formal action barely moved, and the exception is where performance changed the outcome. It starts before the violation, in trust, and it reaches coworkers, who are less sure the same rules apply to everyone.

Where do I stand on trust? Trust built on a record is reasonable… the exception, especially the first one, is where it needs a record of its own. A written reason for any departure from policy, reviewed by someone outside the reporting line, gives that trust a structure to rest on, and a human still makes the call.

About the Report

The Performance Privilege Report is a GCheck Compliance for Good® report based on a randomized experiment fielded November 5, 2026 via Pollfish with 2,000 employed US adults, including 893 managers. It tests how an employee’s performance level changes the way managers judge identical misconduct and what coworkers expect once someone reports it. The full report, including methodology and the findings that cut the other way, is available at gcheck.com/whitepapers/performance-privilege-report/.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Performance Privilege?

Performance Privilege is the tendency for an employee’s performance level to change how a manager reads and responds to the same conduct. GCheck uses the term for a pattern found in its November 2026 experiment with 893 US managers, not as a label for any manager or employee. In the study, managers gave a top performer more benefit of the doubt before the facts were settled and were more likely to back an exception after a violation was confirmed.

How was Performance Privilege measured?

A November 5, 2026 survey of 2,000 employed US adults tested it. Each of the 893 managers decided one case, an employee who submits the same expense claim twice, and saw one of five versions that differed only in how much was known and how the employee performed. Because no manager judged more than one employee, gaps between versions come from the description of the employee. The results are stated intentions in a hypothetical case.

Do managers investigate top performers less often?

No. After a duplicate expense was confirmed as knowingly submitted, 96% of managers were very or somewhat likely to investigate further for both a typical and a top performer. Formal warning, discipline or escalation was recommended at similar rates, 68% for a typical performer and 64% for a top performer. The difference appeared in a separate decision: whether to grant an exception to the usual policy.

How much more likely are managers to back an exception for a top performer?

In the quality-checked sample, 49% of managers backed an exception for a top performer who knowingly submitted a duplicate expense, against 27% for a typical performer, which makes managers 1.8 times as likely to back an exception for a top performer. On all responses, the figures were 44% and 33%. The quality-checked sample sets aside responses flagged for speeding, straight-lining or a failed comprehension check.

Why would managers grant top performers more leniency?

Managers who decided the top-performer case named many reasons, and no single reason reached a majority. Grouped by type, trust-based reasons outnumbered retention-based ones, 30% to 21%. Separately, 67% of managers said they would respond more harshly to a repeat incident, at similar rates for every performer. The stated reasons lean toward trust in a reliable person more than toward retaining them.

Do managers think policy should apply equally to everyone?

In principle, yes. 81% of managers say company policy should be enforced the same way regardless of performance, yet 59% say high performers at their own organization receive more leniency when they break a rule. Half of all managers (50%) agree with both statements, which the report calls Two Rulebooks: managers endorse one standard and describe a second.

What do coworkers expect when a top performer breaks a rule?

After a confirmed violation, 72% of coworkers expected management to handle a typical performer’s case the same way it would for anyone, against 62% for a top performer. Coworkers read the same five scenarios as someone who noticed the duplicate expense. That 10-point gap in confidence matters because fear of inaction is one documented reason people do not report workplace harassment (EEOC, 2016).

What can HR teams do to reduce Performance Privilege?

The report points to the exception as the most direct lever. Its four practices: require a written rationale, reviewed outside the reporting line, for any exception to a conduct or expense policy; record the same incident details for every employee; give coworkers a channel to raise inconsistent treatment and close the loop with them without sharing confidential personnel details; and train managers to name what is driving a decision. A human still makes each decision, and legal counsel should review how these fit a given workforce and jurisdiction.

Pat Hartonian
ABOUT THE CREATOR

Pat Hartonian

Chief Compliance Officer

Pat Hartonian is the Chief Compliance Officer at GCheck, where he leads compliance strategy and ensures every background screening program meets the highest standards of accuracy, regulatory alignment, and fairness. He brings over 15 years of executive experience in the background screening industry, with deep expertise in criminal records research, employment and education verification, and FCRA compliance frameworks.

Pat holds an Advanced FCRA certification from PBSA, a certification in Generative AI and Large Language Models from AWS, and completed the CORe program from Harvard Business School Online. He is also the author of Decoding Humans: How Fear, Happiness, and AI Shape Every Decision We Make, where he explores the intersection of ethics, decision-making, and emerging technologies..